Faculty of Applied Sciences

Permanent URI for this communityhttp://ir-dev.dut.ac.za/handle/10321/5

Browse

Now showing 1 - 20 of 52

Application of lipid extracted algae in feed and energy production
(2019) Ansari, Faiz Ahmad; Bux, Faizal; Gupta, Sanjay Kumar; Guldhe, Abhishek
Microalgae are well considered to be promising feedstocks for biodiesel production. Microalgae can be grown under different types of cultivation conditions and their biomass has tremendous potential to be used as biofuel feedstock and for other applications such as feed, food, cosmetics, pharmaceutical etc. Despite the many benefits and the significant development in the field of microalgal biodiesel production, there are several challenges including high cultivation cost and developing efficient downstream processing methods. The biomass production cost is high, which significantly hinders the use of microalgae as a feedstock. Most of the available literature is focused on upstream, single strain and single product strategy, where mainly algal lipids are used for biofuel production. Hence, for improving the sustainability of the algal biofuel production processes and related process economics, a multiple applications approach using integrated biorefinery and exploiting microalgae for environmental benefits is required. To explore the microalgal biorefinery concept it is vital to understand the various cultivation conditions and applications of biomass in different sectors. There are various strategies, which have potential to make algal biofuel technologies more economically feasible and environmentally sustainable. Use of alternative culture media, improving the biomass production and the efficiency of downstream processing (drying, cell disruption, lipid extraction etc.) algal biofuel technology economical. Utilizing lipid-extracted algae (LEA) for energy and aqua feed application will maximize overall economic return and will leave minimal residues as by-product. The major focus of this thesis was to utilize LEA as substrate for biomethane production and protein source in aquaculture feed. However, effect of preceding steps such as microalgae cultivation, biomass drying and cell disruption on major metabolites extraction was also studied. Microalgae were cultivated in different medium (domestic wastewater and BG11) and their biomass yields and biochemical composition (lipid, protein and carbohydrate) were compared. Different drying and cell disruption techniques were employed for lipid extraction and their effect on lipid, protein and carbohydrate yields were evaluated. The yield of major metabolites on whole cell and LEA were also compared. Suitable solvent systems were selected for optimum lipid extraction from wet and dry biomass with minimal toxic effect on LEA metabolites so that LEA can be further used for biomethane and aquaculture feed production. The choice of microalgae at large scale depends upon the number of factors such as their adaptability to large-scale cultivation, biomass production, major metabolites content, robustness towards the open system cultivation and contamination. In this study, S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana were cultivated in wastewater and BG11 medium at laboratory scale. Both strains are indigenous to KwaZulu-Natal. C. sorokiniana showed lower biomass and major metabolites (lipid, protein and carbohydrate) production at large scale compared to S. obliquus. Considering better adaptability to open cultivation, high biomass and metabolites yields, S. obliquus strain was selected for the LEA application study. Microalgae species, C. sorokiniana and S. obliquus were cultivated on BG11 and using different ratios of raw domestic wastewater and post-chlorinated wastewater as nutrient media. The cultivation of S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana showed biomass yield of 1.2-3.5 and 0.78-1.8 g L-1 in BG11 medium, respectively. While biomass yield observed in wastewater was 0.59-1.59 g L-1 for S. obliquus and 0.67-1.45 g L-1 for C. sorokiniana. The higher biomass yield in BG11 medium attributed to the higher nutrient contents in this medium compared to wastewater. The lipid contents for S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana were 20 and 16.5% dry cell weight (DCW), respectively when grown using BG11 medium. While increases in lipid contents of 26.25 and 29.4% DCW were found for S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana, respectively when cultivated using wastewater. Similarly, carbohydrate contents for S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana were 18 and 17% DCW, respectively for BG11 medium. Increased in carbohydrate contents of 25% for S. obliquus, 28.4% DCW for C. sorokiniana were observed for wastewater. Microalgae tend to accumulate more lipids and/or carbohydrates under nutrient stress condition. The nitrogen and phosphorus contents in wastewater are lower than BG11 medium, which were responsible for stressed condition for microalgae. With limited nutrients in wastewater compared to BG11 medium, growth of microalgae is also lower which resulted in lower protein content. Protein content for S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana in BG11 medium were 37.83-48.8 and 25-35.3% DCW, respectively. The protein contents for S. obliquus and C. sorokiniana in wastewater medium were 16.4-27.29 and 15.8-27.3% DCW, respectively. The biochemical composition depends upon the nutrient composition of the medium and cultivation conditions. The two selected microalgae have shown potential for nutrient removal while cultivated in wastewater. The removal efficiency by S. obliquus was found to be 76.13% for COD, 98.54% for nitrogen and 97.99% for phosphate. Microalgae C. sorokiniana cultivation in wastewater removed 69.38% COD, 86.93% nitrogen and 68.24% phosphates. Increased lipid accumulation in the cells was also recorded in stressed conditions due to low nutrient availability from wastewater. After harvesting of microalgae from culture media, the water content in thick algal slurry (>85% DCW) lowers the products recovery. To overcome this challenge drying and cell disruption are required to enhance the efficiency of lipid extraction. Where drying and cell disruption increase the viability of biomass for lipid extraction process. Three biomass-drying techniques viz. sun, oven and freeze-drying and four-cell disruption techniques viz. microwave, sonication, osmotic shock and autoclave disruption were studied for their effect on recovery of major metabolites from S. obliquus. Microalgae metabolites recovery from whole cell and LEA were analysed and compared. The results showed that after lipid extraction, LEA still contained comparable protein to whole algae biomass however, the carbohydrate concentration was reduced. Oven drying exhibited the highest recovery of all the major metabolites followed by freeze-drying; sun drying however, showed lower yields. Despite lower metabolites recovery sun-drying technique is preferable at large scale due to its easy application and cost-effective nature. The main drawback of sun drying technique is weather dependence and required longer period to dry. The microwave and autoclave microalgal cell disruption improved the lipid yield but loss of other compounds was observed. In osmotic shock treatment, due to poor cell disruption efficiency low lipid were obtained and comparably lower protein loss was noticed during lipid extraction. Lipid extraction is crucial step for microalgae biodiesel production. Solvent-assisted lipid extraction is widely used technique for lipid recovery from dry or wet algae biomass. In a biorefinery approach, it is vital to choose appropriate solvents for the optimum lipid extraction whilst having minimal effect on the remaining metabolites (protein and carbohydrates) in LEA. LEA could be used for energy generation or aquaculture feed applications. Six commonly used organic solvents/ solvent systems were used for lipid extraction from wet and dry biomass. The results showed that the lipid extraction efficiency depends strongly on types of biomass as well as solvent systems selected. Lipid extraction from wet algal biomass could reduce the processing steps and save energy incurred in drying. However, the water present in wet algal slurry acts as a barrier, which results in lower lipid yield compared to the dry biomass. The results revealed that among all six-selected solvents, chloroform: ethanol (1:1 v/v) was most effective if wet biomass used specifically for lipid purpose only. To explore the biorefinery concept, isopropanol/hexane composition is the most suitable solvent system because it is less toxic and resulted in high protein (20.07% DCW) and carbohydrate (22.87%) yields in LEA. For dry algal biomass, chloroform: methanol (2:1 v/v) is an appropriate solvent system if biomass used especially for lipid (19.25%) extraction. If LEA to be used for energy and/or aquaculture feed application, DCM: methanol was found to be a suitable solvent system, which gave 32.79% protein and 26.92% carbohydrate yield. Comparatively hexane has lower lipid recovery but shown higher protein and carbohydrate yield in LEA. Due to less toxic, easy to scale up and inexpensive, hexane is preferable as a solvent for lipid extraction if LEA is to be further utilized at large scale for energy or feed application. Anaerobic digestion (AD) of organic residues is well-researched technology for biomethane production. Whole microalgae and LEA has promising potential for biomethane production. The anaerobic sludge used as inoculum for microalgal biomass digestion. Biomethane production from whole algae and products extracted algae highly depends on sludge to algae biomass ratio for higher methane production. The extraction of metabolites also changes the biochemical composition of residual biomass, which can affect the biomethane production. It is vital to understand the effect of various product-extracted algae and as well as pre-treated algae on the biochemical methane potential. In order to compare biomethane potential, four types of biomass were selected namely sun dried powder algae (SDPA), mild heat-treated algae (MHTA), LEA (using hexane as lipid extracting solvent) and protein-extracted algae (PEA). The average methane (CH4) production rate was ~ 2.5 times higher for protein and lipid extracted algae than for whole algae SDPA and MHTA whilst the cumulative CH4 production was higher for pre-treated algae. Highest cumulative CH4 production (318.7mL CH4 g-1 VS) was found for MHTA followed by SDPA (307.4mL CH4 g-1 VS). The CH4/CO2 ratios of 1.5 and 0.7 were observed for MHTA and LEA, respectively. Outcome of this objective revealed that pre-treatment process disrupts the microalgae cell walls, exposing intracellular material and increasing the surface area. The product-extracted algae changes the elemental composition, which decreases the cumulative gas yield CH4/CO2 ratio. Presence of high nitrogen in the form of protein produces ammonia (NH3) which inhibits the methane production. Therefore, it is imperative to use PEA biomass to improve the methane production yield than the whole cell biomass. Due to escalating price and unstable supply of fish meal (FM), alternative protein sources are used in aqua feed, however these sources do not meet to the requirement. The use of less expensive protein source in aquaculture feed as alternative to FM is required. Microalgae are primary producers in the food chain as well as a natural food for fish. Microalgal biomass is comprised of proteins, lipids, carbohydrates, pigments and many other bioactive compounds. The microalgal proteins have an appropriate balance of all essential amino acids, while lipids are rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids (omega-3 fatty acids, EPA, DHA). Whole algae contain all required ingredients while LEA also contain protein, carbohydrates, vitamins, bioactive compounds even though most of the lipid soluble nutrients have been removed. Thus, microalgae have promising potential to be used in aquaculture feed. Aquaculture production continues to increase globally, to meet the aquaculture feed demand algae supplemented aquaculture feed will play an important role in providing good quality fish. In this study, approximately 200 kg of microalgal biomass was harvested for the feed application. Due to lower toxicity, ease of availability and ease of recovery from mixture, hexane was used as a lipid extracting solvent at pilot scale to generate LEA. The 44 weeks (from juvenile to finisher stage) feeding trials were conducted to evaluate the effect of whole and LEA supplementation of S. obliquus strain on growth performance, disease tolerance, feed utilization, physiological activity, and fillet biochemical composition of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). In the first trial, fish were fed with an algae free diet (control) and four experimental diets (2.5, 5, 7.5 and 10 wt%) as protein source of dried S. obliquus. The study showed that microalgae could be used as a protein supplement in the Tilapia feed for enhancement of morphological characteristics and nutritional value. The 7.5% and 10% supplementation of whole algal biomass in tilapia feed showed significant improvement in weight and length of the fish compared to the control. The daily body weight gain was 0.25 g higher in experimental groups than the control. The hepatosomatic index percentage was also higher in fish feed when 7.5% whole algae was used in fish feed as a protein source. The results also showed that 7.5% and 10% have better specific growth rate (1.57 and 1.5%), daily body weight gain (1.1 and 0.86 g), overall body weight gain (427.16 and 331.48 g), protein assimilation (43.96 and 40.46%) higher than the control diet fed fish. The survival rate of fish were 100% at every inclusion level. In second trial (44 weeks), two supplementations (7.5 and 10 wt%) of LEA as protein source were used in Nile tilapia diets. Results showed 7.5% and 10% LEA supplemented feed shown better growth performance than control. The protein content were 42.2%, 41.3% and 36.1% in tilapia fed with 7.5%, 10% LEA and control feed, respectively. The body weight gain, tilapia fed with 7.5% LEA shown 357 g while 10% LEA and control have 331.78 g, and 330.08 gm, respectively. The application of whole and LEA of S. obliquus in tilapia feed, shown appropriate supplementation level for tilapia feed at demonstration scale. This thesis presents advances in knowledge in the field of microalgae biorefinery research for pilot scale operations. This research work has covered various aspects such as effect of drying, cell disruption and lipid extraction on whole and LEA metabolites yield. The extraction of lipid from wet and dry microalgal biomass using various solvent systems provides a new insight for the selection of appropriate solvent systems, which can be used for the large-scale lipid extraction. The study on LEA for biomethane production enhances the understanding about the effects of different pre-treatments and product extractions on biomethane production. The results revealed that the supplementation of whole cell and LEA using S. obliquus for tilapia feed is safe therefore, can be used as an alternative protein source. The findings of this study have both academic and industrial value.
Assessment of a biological nutrient removal process for the remediation of edible oil effluent
(2002-05-10) Mkhize, Sandile Psychology; Bux, Faizal
Eutrophication is a natural process that is greatly aggravated by the action of man in the natural environment. Deterioration of South Africa's natural water resources results directly or indirectly from the discharge of industrial effluent rich in nutrient nitrogen and phosphorus. The South African edible oil refmeries generally discharge poor quality effluent which impacts negatively on the water resources and wastewater treatment installations. The main aim of this study was to assess the capacity of a laboratory scale effluent treatment process that will produce final effluent of acceptable quality with regards to organic load and phosphate concentration prior to its discharge into the municipal sewerage system. The study was conducted in three stages: wastewater characterization, treatability studies, and laboratory scale treatment investigations. After analysing various effluent parameters, treatability studies were conducted using an aerobic-anaerobic sequencing batch reactor with a total hydraulic retention time of 24 hours. The results showed an average of 75 % reduction of COD and more than 90 % removal of fats, oils and grease (FOG). Based on the results of effluent characterisation and treatability studies, a laboratory scale activated sludge effluent treatment process was designed and operated with two bioreactors (aerobic and anaerobic) in series. The system was operated for a period of one-month resulting in 70 % removal of COD and 4% reduction in phosphate (P04-P). After some structural and operational changes from the original design configuration, the system was the operated continuously for the duration of the study period. An optimum COD removal of 75 % and 107 mgll P04-P reduction was achieved during the last operational phase of the system. More than 95 % reduction in fats, oils and grease (FOG) had been achieved in both semi-continuously and continuously operated systems.b.7
Assessment of biomarkers for normalization of SARS-CoV-2 concentrations in wastewater
(2023-09) Osman, Aaliyah; Sheena, Kumari; Amoah, Isaac Dennis; Bux, Faizal
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the measurement of SARS-CoV-2 RNA levels in wastewater quickly emerged as an additional tool for monitoring and to provide an early warning system. This led to development of several regional, national and international projects aimed at applying this approach. The main principle is based on the detection of the viral signature in untreated wastewater to provide an indication of infection levels within connected populations. However, the concentration of the viral signature in wastewater can be impacted by dilution factors or population changes in the sewer shed, leading to misinterpretation of measurement results. Therefore, there is the need for normalization of wastewater to ensure accurate representation of infection numbers. The aim of this study was to evaluate different viral and bacterial markers in wastewater for their efficiency in normalizing SARS-CoV-2 WBE data, which will enhance the accuracy when interpreting the SARS-CoV-2 RNA concentrations in wastewater. Weekly sampling was conducted from two wastewater treatment plants (WWTP A and WWTP B) within the eThekwini district over a period of three months (July-October 2022). Three biomarkers (crAssphage, Bacteroides (HF 183), and Pepper Mild Motile Virus) where chosen for this study to ascertain the most suitable for WBE data normalization. Biomarker and SARS CoV-2 concentrations in the wastewater samples were determined using the droplet digital PCR (ddPCR). Physicochemical characteristics of the wastewater samples were also determined to identify the potential impact of these characteristics on the concentration of SARS-CoV-2 and the biomarkers. To determine the most suitable biomarker, correlation analysis and the Adaptive neuro fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) model was used. Average concentrations of SARS-CoV-2 in the sampled WWTPs ranged from 0.28 copies/µL to 9.57 copies/µL. Among the three biomarkers studied, crAssphage recorded the highest concentration compared to PMMoV and Bacteroides HF183 in both the WWTPs. CrAssphage recorded the highest concentration of 7943 (±7.07) copies/µL for WWTP A and 8006 (±4.24) copies/µL for WWTP B. The Bacteroides HF183 highest concentrations were 10116 (±120.91) copies/µL for WWTP A and 2474 (±117.37) copies/µL for WWTP B. PMMoV had concentrations of 46 (±4.24) copies/µL for WWTP A and 84,1 (±5.48) copies/µL for WWTP B. PMMoV concentrations were observed to be the highest at Week 1. CrAssphage showed a greater association during the trend analysis with SARS-CoV-2 (0.499) than the other two biomarkers for WWTP A, (HF 183 and SARS-CoV-2 (-0.191) and PMMoV and SARS-CoV 2 (-0.562)). Among the physicochemical factors studied, electrical conductivity and temperature had a significant correlation with SARS-CoV-2 and the crAssphage biomarker for both WWTPs. Using the ANFIS model, it was shown that the levels of the measured biomarker concentrations in wastewater had a significant association with chemical oxygen demand (COD), dissolved oxygen (DO), and volatile solids (VS). These results indicate a possible impact of these parameters on the concentration of these biomarkers in the wastewater. Furthermore, the viral RNA quantities of SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater were demonstrated to be influenced by other parameters such as electrical conductivity, pH and temperature. This indicates a difference in the physicochemical parameters that influence both biomarkers and SARS-CoV-2. However, when all physicochemical parameters, biomarkers and SARS-CoV-2 were combined, it was determined that the best biomarker was crAssphage, with potential impact from COD and the VS. The results of this study highlight the significance of including wastewater characteristic in WBE studies for reliable and accurate results. As shown in this study, crAssphage can serve ix as a biomarker for efficient WBE for COVID-19 surveillance. In addition, it has been demonstrated that the detection and quantification of targets of concern, including SARS-CoV 2, may be enhanced when combined with wastewater characteristics, which may enhance the monitoring of COVID-19 infections.
Assessment of heavy metals and pathogens removal from municipal wastewater using a constructed rhizofiltration system
(2018) Odinga, Christine Akinyi; Swalaha, Feroz Mahomed; Bux, Faizal; Otieno, Fredrick Alfred O.
Wastewater discharged from municipal treatment plants contain a mixture of organic contaminants, trace metals, enteric pathogens, viruses, and inorganic materials. The presence of such pollutants in wastewater poses a huge challenge to the choice and applications of the preferred treatment method. Conventional treatment methods are inefficient in the removal of some environmentally toxic pollutants and pathogens. This study evaluated the effectiveness of a constructed rhizofiltration system in the removal of heavy metals and enteric pathogens from municipal wastewater. The study was conducted at an eThekwini municipal wastewater treatment plant in Kingsburgh - Durban in the province of KwaZulu-Natal. The pilot-scale rhizofiltration unit included three different layers of substrates consisting of medium stones, coarse gravel and fine sand. The system had one section planted with Phragmites australis and Kyllinga nemoralis while the other section was unplanted and acted as the reference section. Influent and effluent, plant tissue and sediment from the rhizofilter were sampled bi-monthly for a period of two years and assessed for the presence and removal of selected enteric pathogens, trace heavy metals and changes in physicochemical and biological parameters using standard methods. Antibacterial potential of the two experimental plants was determined by the agar-well diffusion method using plant root exudates exposed to selected pathogenic bacteria. Observation of details of plant morphology, distribution and assessment of the metals attachment onto the various plant tissues was determined using images from scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The Langmuir model was used to assess the heavy metal adsorption of the plants. There was an increase in pH from 6.95 pH units to 7.55 pH units in the planted and 6.72 to 7.23 pH units in the reference sections. There was an average reduction in biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) by 79% and chemical oxygen demand (COD) by 75%. Suspended solids were reduced by 86% in the planted section and 59.8% in the reference section, Electrical conductivity was reduced by 7.7% in the planted section and 0.83% in the reference section, Total Dissolved Solids was reduced by 11.5% in the planted section and 3.5% in the reference section, temperature was reduced by 11.9% in the planted section and 1.2% in the reference section, while dissolved oxygen was raised by 10% in the planted section and 5% in the reference section. Turbidity was reduced by 9.7 NTU in the planted section and 9.1 NTU in the reference section, while alkalinity was reduced by 46.3% in planted and 45.5% on reference sections of the rhizofilter. There was a significant reduction in organic loading in the system which was statistically significant (phosphorous, p = 0.029; ammonia, p = 0.03).These average reductions and increases were observed after the system was fully established. The results indicate a comparatively better removal efficiency in the planted than the reference sections of the system. Considering the entire rhizofilter, heavy metals were accumulated at varying percentages of 96.69% on planted and 48.98% in reference sections for cadmium. Chromium was 81% and 24%, Copper was 23.4% and 1.1%, Nickel was 72% and 46.5, Lead was 63% and 31%, while Zinc was 76% and 84% in the planted and reference section of the rhizofilter respectively. The planted section had a much higher removal efficiency as compared to the reference section of the rhizofilter. The macrophytes were found to display some metals binding potential according to observations from SEM and EDX analysis. Significant amounts of Cu deposits were recorded on the roots of K. nemoralis at 0.31wt% with a peak at 0.6cps/eV than on P. australis which was at 0.31wt% with a peak at 0.6cps/eV. Further, higher deposits of Ni at 0.01 wt% with peak at 0.5 cps/eV and 0.0 wt% with peak at 0.2 cps/eV, Pb at 0.22 wt% with peak at 0.2 cps/eV and 0.21wt% with peak at 0.2 cps/eV were recorded on the roots of K. nemoralis and P. australis respectively. Kyllinga nemoralis was found to have greater metals adsorptive capabilities than P. australis. The planted and reference sections had varied removal capacities of between 45% and 98% for the various pathogens detected in the influent wastewater. For example, the concentration of coliphage was reduced by 94.6% in the planted section and 93.6% in the reference section, Candida spp. removal was 64.7% in the planted section and 62.5% in the reference section. Escherichia coli was reduced by 65%- 85% while Salmonella spp. was removed by 94% in the planted section compared to 78% in the reference section. Ascaris lumbricoides was reduced by 77% in the planted section and 53% in the reference section. Accordingly, higher pathogens reduction was achieved in the planted section as compared to the reference section of the rhizofilter. Root exudates from Kyllinga nemoralis were found to display a wider zone of growth inhibition at 9.97±0.19 mm compared to P. australis which had a zone of 8.63 ± 0.22 mm when exposed to cultured colonies of Escherichia coli.
Assessment of microalgal ACCase and rbcl gene expression as a function of nutrient and metal stress
(2017) Singh, Poonam; Bux, Faizal; Kumari, Sheena K.; Guldhe, Abhishek
Microalgae are considered to be a potential feedstock for biodiesel production. However, the main concern with regard to the large scale microalgal biodiesel production process is its competence and economic viability. The commercial realization of microalgal biodiesel production requires substantial impetus towards development of efficient strategies to improve lipid yields upstream. Nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) stress during cultivation are the widely used lipid accumulation strategies for microalgae. However, these individual nutrient stress strategies are associated with compromised biomass productivity which hampers overall lipid productivity. Lipid enhancement strategies based on light, temperature and CO2 are associated with technological barriers for scale up and incur additional cost. Thus, the main aim of this study was to develop an integrated, easily applicable and scalable lipid enhancement strategy based on nutrients and metals such as N, P, iron (Fe), magnesium (Mg), calcium (Ca) and EDTA stress for selected indigenous microalgal strains. The effect of metal concentrations individually and in combination on microalgal lipids and biomass production is a scarcely exploited area. In this study, a novel approach involving individual as well as combined metals and EDTA stress under N and P limited conditions for lipid enhancement in microalgae was investigated. Microalgal growth physiology, photosynthetic performance, biochemical composition (lipid, carbohydrate and protein) and expression of selected key genes involved in photosynthesis (rbcL) and fatty acid biosynthesis (accD) were studied both under selected individual and combined stress conditions. Out of seven microalgal isolates obtained during the initial isolation and screening process, two strains were selected for lipid enhancement study based on their growth rates, biomass yields, lipid content and lipid productivities. The strains were later identified as Acutodesmus obliquus and Chlorella sorokiniana based on both morphological characteristics and phylogenetical analysis. The selected strains were thereafter subjected to different cultivation conditions involving varying metal, EDTA and nutrient stress conditions. A significant increase in lipid productivity was observed when the concentrations of Fe, Mg and EDTA were increased and Ca was decreased to degree in the N and P stress BG11 medium. For A. obliquus, a highest lipid productivity of 80.23 mgL-1d-1 was achieved with the developed strategy under limited N (750 mg L-1) condition which was 2.18 fold higher than BG11 medium and 1.89 fold higher than N limited condition alone. Similarly, for C. sorokiniana, highest lipid productivity of 77.03 mgL-1d-1 was achieved with the developed strategy under limited N (500 mgL-1) and P (10 mgL-1) which was 2.67 fold higher than BG11 medium and 2.35 fold higher than N and P limited condition alone. For both the microalgal strains, Fe was the most significant trace metal affecting their lipid productivity. These above observations were further confirmed through photosynthetic performance analysis and gene expression studies. At mid log phase, 6.38 and 5.15 fold increases in the expression levels of rbcL gene were observed under combined stress (OCMS+OE) as compared to the control (BG11) condition in A. obliquus and C. sorokiniana respectively. This also resulted in an increased expression level of accD gene involved in lipid biosynthesis to 10.25 fold and 9.79 fold in A. obliquus and C. sorokiniana respectively at late log phase. The results from expression studies of rbcL and accD genes were in compliance with biomass yields, photosynthetic performance, protein yield and lipid productivities for both the strains under different cultivating conditions. The universal applicability of the above strategy was confirmed by applying it to five other microalgae strains isolated in this study which resulted in considerable increase in their overall lipid productivity under optimized conditions. Attempts were made to scale up the lab scale study to open circular pond (3000L) cultivation for A. obliquus. Results showed a 2.08 fold increase in lipid productivity under optimized conditions compared to the control, which emphasizes the scalability of the developed strategy even under uncontrolled conditions. In conclusion, the developed combined metal and EDTA stress strategy not only assisted in alleviating the biomass productivity but also enhanced the lipid accumulation which resulted in overall increased lipid productivity under N and P limited condition. Furthermore, the improved carbohydrate and protein productivities observed with the developed lipid enhancement strategy make it suitable for biorefinery approach with multiple products. An improvement in lipid profile and high biodiesel conversion were also observed with this universally applicable and scalable lipid enhancement strategy confirming their potential applicability during large scale cultivation for biodiesel production.
Bioaugmentation with Bacillus spp. for bioremediation of synthetic wastewater using a fluidized-bed reactor
(2020-03-25) Roets, Yrielle; Bux, Faizal; Lalloo, Rajesh; Kumar, Sheena
South Africa’s freshwater resources, including rivers, man-made lakes and groundwater are under severe threat due to an ever-expanding population and economy, which is depleting these resources. The increase in population has a direct correlation with the increase in wastewater generated. The remaining fresh water resources need to be preserved therefore recycling of wastewater, to replenish our water supplies and preserve the environment, is a solution to the problem. For a developing country, it is important to use treatment methods that are cost effective and do not exert a negative impact on the environment, such as biological wastewater treatment options. One of the systems commonly used in biological wastewater treatment is the fluidized-bed bioreactor (FBBR) due to its advantages such as higher biomass concentration and a higher mass transfer thus resulting in a higher rate of biodegradation. This study focused on evaluating the efficacy of augmenting with Bacillus spp. to enhance the bioremediation of wastewater using a FBBR. Bacillus spp. used in this study were isolated from a municipal wastewater treatment plant (10 isolates) and the remaining three isolates were selected from the CSIR Bacillus database. The isolates (13 in total) were screened for 1) their ability grow in wastewater, 2) ability to reduce high concentrations of COD, ammonium, nitrates and phosphates in flask studies containing synthetic wastewater (SWW) and 3) ability to produce common enzymes such as amylase, cellulase, lipase and protease. Isolates showed varying bioremediation potential for different compounds analysed. Isolate B006 showed the highest phosphate removal rate (3.290 mg.L-1.h-1) where as D005 showed the highest growth rate (0.955 h-1), COD reduction rate (55 mg.L-1.h-1) and cellulase activity (5.485 mm) among all the isolates. Isolate D014 presented the highest ammonium removal rate (12.43 mg.L-1.h-1), amylase (5.00 mm) and protease (10.00 mm) activity whilst B001 displayed the highest nitrate removal rate (9.4 mg.L-1.h-1). The results for the individual assays were assessed and weighted in a matrix and the isolates that scored above 50% were selected for consortium studies. Four Bacillus spp. that scored above 50% in the scoring matrix were then evaluated for their ability to co-exist as a consortium. The consortium studies were then compared with results obtained for individual isolates. The selected Bacillus isolates were identified and assessed for their safety to the environment and to the end user. Identification was conducted using 16s rDNA sequencing and results showed that B006 identified as B. cereus, D005 as B. cereus and D014 as B. subtilis. Isolates, B006 and D005 were further assessed for enterotoxin production and the presence of anthrax virulent plasmids pX01 and pX02. After conducting the biosafety assays, the isolates were rendered safe for use. The isolates were then cryopreserved as spores in 25% glycerol and stored at -80 °C. The impact of the cryopreservation method and the storage conditions on the viability of the isolates was assessed after six months of storage and it was established that the isolates were still viable and that the method was adequate. The bioremediation potential of the consortium was further evaluated using a 17 L Pilot scale fluidised-bed bioreactor. The reactors were fed at three different flow rates of 1.5 L.h-1, 2 L.h-1 and 3 L.h-1 over steady state conditions (~3months). The results showed that the FBBR augmented with the selected Bacillus isolates, resulted in improved nutrient (COD, ammonium and phosphates) removal efficiencies compared to the non-bioaugmented control. The highest ammonium removal (62.8%) was observed at a flow rate of 1.5 L.h-1 (11.30 h retention time), whereby there was an overall 29.8% improvement in ammonia removal in comparison to the non-augmented control. Similarly, an overall improvement in phosphate (14.73%) was observed at a flow rate of 2 L.h-1 (8.48 h retention time) with 50% removal efficiency. The highest COD removal was observed at a flow rate of 1.5 L.h-1 (11.30 h retention time) whereby 74.5% COD was reduced with a 32.6% improvement when compared to the non-bioaugmented control. Our work has demonstrated the potential application of Bacillus as bioaugmentation agents to enhance wastewater treatment efficiency as a potential solution to water challenges in developing countries. This technology could also be utilized for addressing the challenges of a wider range of different effluents.
Biodiesel production from microalgae by enzymatic transesterification
(2015) Guldhe, Abhishek; Bux, Faizal; Permaul, Kugen; Mutanda, Taurai
Main focus of this study is to investigate the enzymatic-conversion of microalgal lipids to biodiesel. However, preceding steps before conversion such as drying of microalgal biomass and extraction of lipids were also studied. Downstream processing of microalgae has several challenges and there is very little literature available in this area. S. obliquus was grown in the pilot scale open pond cultivation system for biomass production. Different techniques were studied for biomass drying and extraction of lipids from harvested microalgal biomass. Effect of these drying and extraction techniques on lipid yield and quality was assessed. Energy consumption and economic evaluation was also studied. Enzymatic conversion of microalgal lipids by extracellular and whole cell lipase application was investigated. For both applications, free and immobilized lipases from different sources were screened and selected based on biodiesel conversion. Process parameters were optimized using chosen extracellular and whole cell lipases; also step-wise methanol addition was studied to improve the biodiesel conversion. Immobilized lipase was studied for its reuse. Final biodiesel was characterized for its fuel properties and compared with the specifications given by international standards. Enzymatic conversion of microalgal lipids was compared with the conventional homogeneous acid-catalyzed conversion. Enzymatic conversion and chemical conversion were techno-economically investigated based on process cost, energy consumption and processing steps. Freeze drying was the most efficient technique, however at large scale economical sun drying could also be selected as possible drying step. Microwave assisted lipid extraction performed better compared to sonication technique. Immobilized P. fluorescens lipase in extracellular application and A. niger lipase in whole cell application showed superior biodiesel conversion. The extracellular immobilized P. fluorescens lipase showed better biodiesel conversion and yields than the immobilized A. niger whole cell lipase. Both the enzyme catalysts showed lower biodiesel conversion compared to conventional chemical catalyst and higher processing cost. However, techno-economic analysis showed that, the reuse potential of immobilized lipases can significantly improve the economics. Fewer purification steps, less wastewater generation and minimal energy input are the benefits of enzymatic route of biodiesel conversion. Microalgae as a feedstock and lipase as a catalyst for conversion makes overall biodiesel production process environmentally-friendly. Data from this study has academic as well as industrial significance. Conclusions from this study form the basis for greener and sustainable scaling-up of microalgal biodiesel production process.
Biological phosphorus removal from edible oil effluent by anaerobic- aerobic sequencing batch reactor
(2004) Manganyi, Abel Jwili; Bux, Faizal
The objective of this study was to evaluate the characteristics and treatability of process wastewater from an edible oil refining industry, which discharge its effluent into a sewer system. The main objective was to assess a laboratory scale treatment process that would produce effluent having a regulatory acceptable phosphate concentration (below 20 mgIL) prior to discharge into municipal sewer system. A single stage laboratory-scale anaerobic-aerobic sequencing batch reactor (BPR-SBR) with a total volume adjustable up to 10L was designed for biological phosphorus removal. The BPR-SBR was run at 10 days sludge age, 8 hours hydraulic retention time and organic load of ~ 0.38 kg COD/kg MLSS.d for 158 days to evaluate its performance for bio-P removal efficiency. The BPR-SBR system showed a consistent P removal efficiency of up to 78.40 %, 80.15 % COD and 72.43 % FOG reduction. The laboratory scale study has demonstrated that the SBR technology is suitable for treating wastewater from edible oil producing industry.
Characterisation of the microbial communities present in an anaerobic baffled reactor utilising molecular techniques
(2005) Lalbahadur, Tharnija; Bux, Faizal
The provision of safe and sanitary water is a constitutional right and above all, a necessity of life. As a result of the rapid urbanisation and the past policies of apartheid, a large population of South Africa dwell in informal settlements, where there is very little hope of development, as the government does not possess the resources that are necessary for a full-scale sanitation programme. Therefore, on-site treatments have been considered to provide sanitation in these dense peri-urban areas. The anaerobic baffled reactor (ABR) is one such sanitation system. This reactor utilises the phenomenon of anaerobic digestion to degrade substrates. One of the major disadvantages of any anaerobic treatment processes is the extreme sensitivity of the bacterial communities, thus inducing slow recovery rates following toxic shocks. Therefore, an understanding of these microbial consortia is essential to effectively control, operate and optimise the anaerobic reactor. Fluorescence in situ hybridization, 4’,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) staining and DNA sequencing techniques were applied to determine the microbial consortium, as well as their reactions to daily operating conditions. With an understanding of these populations and their responses to perturbations within the system, it is possible to construct an anaerobic system that is successful in its treatment of domestic wastewater. In situ hybridizations were conducted for three operating periods, each characterised by specific flow rates. Results showed Eubacterial population dominance over the Archaeal population throughout both of the operating periods investigated. However, these cells cumulatively consisted of 50% of the total biomass fraction, as determined by DAPI staining. Group-probes utilised revealed a high concentration of fermentative acidogenic bacteria, which lead to a decrease in the pH values. It was noted that the ABR did not separate the acidogenic and methanogenic phases, as expected. Therefore, the decrease in pH further inhibited the proliferation of Archaeal acetoclastic methanogens, which were not present in the second operating period. DNA sequencing results revealed the occurrence of the hydrogenotrophic Methanobacterium and Methanococcus genera and confirmed the presence of Methanosarcina. Sequencing of the bacterial DNA confirmed the presence of the low G+ C Gram Positives (Streptococcus), the high G+C Gram Positives (Propionibacterium) and the sulfate reducing bacteria (Desulfovibrio vulgaris). However, justifications were highly subjective due to a lack of supportive analytical data, such as acetate, volatile fatty acids and methane concentrations. Despite this, findings served to add valuable information, providing details on the specific microbial groups associated with ABR treatment processes.
A combined metagenomics and metatranscriptomics approach to assess the occurrence and reduction of pathogenic bacteria in municipal wastewater treatment plants
(2023-05) Conco, Thobela; Bux, Faizal; Kumari, Sheena; Stenström, Thor-Axel; Ismail, Arshad
The emergence and spread of pathogens, antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistant genes (ARG) through insufficiently treated effluents from wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) pose a risk to human health and the environment. The present study focused on assessing the occurrence, prevalence and fate of dominant pathogenic bacteria, ARGs and mobile genetic element (MGE) in different WWTPs in Durban, Kwa-Zulu Natal, South Africa. The samples were taken from three wastewater treatment plants with different configurations, including trickling filter (TF), biological nutrient removal (BNR), and conventional activated sludge processes (CAS). Total genomic DNA and RNA were extracted from the samples for metagenomic and tracriptomic analysis. A total of 23 pathogenic bacterial genera, including enteric and emerging opportunistic pathogens, were detected in the samples. Acinetobacter spp. and Aeromonas spp. were the predominant pathogens in influent metagenomes, while Escherichia coli and Acinetobacter spp. dominated influent transcripts. Based on Shannon-Wiener indices, the diversity of bacteria increased from influents to final effluents in two treatment plants. ARGsthat confer resistance to aminoglycosides, beta-lactamases, tetracycline and sulfonamides were abundant in both influent and effluent samples. Results further exposed that MGE-ARG associations were the main drivers of ARG persistence to final effluents. This included 5 plasmids: R338-R151 (sulI), pRH-1238 (strB), pPM91 (aadA), pRH-1238 (aadA4-5), pRH-1238 (sulII); two class 1 integrons (aadA and arr) and 1 transposon Tn4351 (tetX). In transcripts, the MGE-ARG associations showed two plasmids: pRH-1238 (aadA) and pPM91 (aadA) and one hybrid plasmid R338-R151 (sulI). The study investigated the potential impact of operational parameters (dissolved oxygen (DO), total suspended solids (TSS), pH and temperature) on selected bacterial pathogens (Aeromonas spp, Acinetobacter spp., Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Klebsiella pneumoniae) and their fates at different stages of the three WWTPs. Principal component analysis (PCA) showed that temperature, DO, and pH were the most relevant factors influencing pathogen abundance. Among the studied pathogens, Acinetobacter spp. was the most prevalent in the influent samples, followed by Aeromonas spp. As for the aeration samples, Aeromonas spp. was dominant in WWTP1 (CAS configuration) and WWTP2 (BNR configuration), while Acinetobacter spp dominated in WWTP3 (BNR configuration). Acinetobacter spp., Aeromonas spp., and Pseudomonas aeruginosa were the dominant ones in secondary effluents, with their dominance varying across the sampling period. In the final treated effluent, Acinetobacterspp., Aeromonas spp., and P. aeruginosa were dominant, with their dominance varying from sample to sample. Additionally, free living amoebas (FLA) were also investigated for their contribution to the propagation and persistence of pathogens in secondary and final effluents. Using the conventional isolation technique, FLAs were isolated from different samples. The internalized bacteria and ARGs were further identified using metagenomic analysis. Metagenomic profiles identified nine species belonging to Acanthamoeba and two species belonging to Entamoeba. A. castellini was the most prevalent dominant species detected in effluent and final effluent samples of all three WWTPs. P. aeruginosa, S. maltophilia, A. spanius, C. testosteroni, and E. cloacae were the most dominant bacterial endosymbionts detected. Among these, S. maltophilia and P. stutzeri were detected in FLAs isolated from the final treated effluents indicating their prevalence in the chlorinated effluents. The presence of ARGs within FLAs were also ascertained. Genes conferring resistance to aminoglycosides (aadA); trimethoprim (dfrA15 and dfrA5); sulfonamides (Sul1 and SulII), macrolides (msrA, mphC); rifamycin (Arr); quinolones (qnrE1) and tetracyclines (TetA and TetG). SulI, dfrA5, AadA, dfrA15, SulII, TetA, TetG and qnrE1 were among the resistance genes that persisted into final effluents. The results of this study have contributed significantly to our current understanding of pathogens, particularly the dominant pathogens and the role of FLAs in the dispersal of pathogens and ARGs into the environment via WWTPs. The study also indicatesthat the conventionally treated effluents may still contain human pathogens, ARGs, and MGEs, which may contribute to the propagation of emerging pathogens and antibiotic resistance in the receiving environment.
A comparative microbiological assessment of river basin sites to elucidate fecal impact and the corresponding risks
(2017) Sithebe, Ayanda; Stenström, Thor-Axel; Singh, Gulshan; Bux, Faizal
The study aims to assess and compare the concentration of microbial contaminants, their sources and distribution in surface water and sediment, and to determine the impact of seasonal variations and corresponding risks of faecal contamination using conventional and molecular methods. Historical data analysis was conducted using E. coli values from the eThekwini Water and Sanitation (EWS) department for 66 months (2009-2014). E. coli and Enterococci were analysed in surface water and sediment samples using the mFC/ spread plate and Colilert-18 (IDEXX) methods. The impact of seasonal variations was assessed using E. coli and Enterococci data collected during rainfall and no rainfall events, using an auto-sampler and sediment trap in parallel. Conventional standard membrane filtration methods using mFC agar, Slanetz & Bartley/ Bile Esculin and Brilliance E. coli selective agar were compared to the enzymatic Colilert-18 and Enterolert (IDEXX) test methods along the Isipingo and Palmiet Rivers. In addition, comparison of the analytical performance of droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) and qPCR for the detection of Salmonella targeting ttr gene in river sediment samples collected from the four sites of the Palmiet River in Durban, South Africa was done. In order to assess the public health risk associated with exposure of men, women and children to microbial pathogens in polluted surface water during recreational activities, the QMRA tool was employed in relation to the risk exposure to pathogenic E. coli, Campylobacter, Salmonella and Shigella. Also, the risk associated with crop irrigation (on farmers) as well as the consumption of crops irrigated with surface water from the Isipingo river was determined. Analysis of the historical data gave a baseline of the two rivers of interest, thus helps understand the current situation of the rivers enabling researchers to pick up potential gaps. In this study after the analysis of the historical data it was evident that at the Palmiet river, microbial analysis must be conducted around the QRI settlements which is a major pollution source. Also, from this study it was found that sampling points situated close to wastewater treatment plants, pump stations or informal settlements were of major concern, thus were considered for the study. It was found that sediment exhibited higher microbial concentrations than surface water, which was observed in both rivers. Also, rainfall had a significant impact on microbial variability. Higher microbial concentrations (indicator organisms) were observed in surface water after a heavy rainfall as appose to when there was no rainfall. This was due to contamination that is washed off into the river and sediment resuspension. Methodology comparison revealed that Colilert-18 and Brilliance E. coli were more selective compared to mFC agar. Brilliance E. coli /Coliform agar was comparable with Colilert-18 IDEXX, which was also observed with Slanetz & Bartley and Enterolert IDEXX. However, when mFC agar was compared with Colilert-18 IDEXX, significant difference was observed. In comparison of two Molecular methods, ddPCR were found to be fully amenable for the quantification of Salmonella and offer robust, accurate, high-throughput, affordable and more sensitive quantitation than qPCR in complex environmental samples like sediments. Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment (QMRA) relating to recreational and occupational exposure showed that children were at the highest risk of getting infected. Also, it was observed that the probability of infection upon exposure to surface water from the Isipingo and Palmiet rivers was significantly high, hence exceeded the WHO guidelines values. Risk assessment on crops revealed that pathogenic bacteria may pose a risk to the consumer, however, a 9-log reduction may be achieved according to the WHO multi-barrier approach which involves proper washing and proper cooking of the crop before ingestion. Overall the sampling points that had the highest pollution level and constantly exceeded the WHO and DWAF guidelines at the Isipingo river were the points situated and named “Next to the WWTP”, and “Downstream of QRI” at the Palmiet River.
Cyanobacteria-microalgae consortia as bio- inoculants for enhancing soil fertility and plant growth
(2024-05) Jose, Shisy; Bux, Faizal; Kumari, Sheena; Renuka, Nirmal; Ratha, Sachitra Kumar
Modern agriculture that heavily utilizes synthetic fertilizers has raised significant environmental concerns worldwide. Microalgae-based bio-inoculants have become a more viable and eco- friendly option to reduce the reliance on chemical fertilizers for improving soil fertility and plant growth in agronomic practices. Indigenous microalgal species can colonize and thrive well under local conditions, making them well-suited for use as bio-inoculants. Additionally, it appears that using microalgal consortia of green microalgae and nitrogen (N)-fixing cyanobacteria could be beneficial because the green microalgae can supply carbon (C), the cyanobacteria can fix C and N in the soil. They both can produce agriculturally beneficial metabolites and improve soil nutrient availability. This synergistic relationship could enhance the overall effectiveness of bio- inoculants and promote sustainable agriculture practices. In this study, thirteen microalgal strains were isolated from agricultural fields of Durban, KwaZulu Natal, South Africa. Two N-fixing cyanobacteria (Nostoc sp. and Calothrix sp.) and two green microalgae (Desmodesmus armatus and Chlorella sp.) strains were selected and analyzed for metabolites of agricultural significance for the development of suitable microalgal consortia under N-deficient conditions. The amount of indole acetic acid (IAA) in biomass extracts from cyanobacteria (Calothrix sp. (2.54 ng g−1) and Nostoc sp. (1.52 ng g−1)) was significantly higher than in extracts from green microalgae (Chlorella sp. (0.32 ng g−1) and Desmodesmus armatus (0.20 ng g−1)). A completely randomized design was used to develop and evaluate eight microalgal consortia on a N-deficient medium with the selected microalgal strains. A significant improvement in biomass productivity, indole acetic acid production, nutrients viz C, N, phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), and manganese (Mn) was observed in the selected consortium compared to the individual isolates. The microalgal consortium was further analyzed for biostimulant properties using seed germination assay in chili seeds. A significant increase in seedling length and leaf number was observed in seeds treated with biomass extracts of consortium compared to the control. The pot culture study also supported the effect of microalgal bio-inoculant on soil fertility, chili plant growth and native soil microbiomes. Soil enzyme activity increased significantly (p < 0.05) with microalgal treatments, with soil dehydrogenase activity (DHA), organic carbon (OC), soil chlorophyll (Chl), total polysaccharides (TP) and nutrients such as C, N, P, K and Mn being more enriched at 100 % and 50 % treatment applications in comparison to control (Cnt). Growth responses in terms of shoot and root (fresh and dry weight), root length and leaf number were significantly high in 50 % microalgal treatments (Al(50 %)+CF(50 %)) when compared to Cnt. With different soil nutrient parameters and microbiome (bacterial and fungal) indicators, we could successfully predict higher soil fertility and plant growth responses to microalgal inoculations. Results using 16SrRNA and ITS amplicon sequencing suggested that microalgal bio-inoculation improved the diversity and composition of native soil microbiome, leading to an increase in soil fertility, plant growth and yield. Further, shotgun metagenomics has confirmed a higher enzymatic activity involved in C, N, and P metabolisms in 50 % and 100 % microalgal treatment compared to the control. Potential shifts in microbial taxa and functional genes indicated that microalgal bio-inoculant was a major driver of microbial metabolic change. The findings from the study suggested that microalgal bio-inoculation improved the diversity and composition of native soil microbiomes, leading to an increase in soil fertility, plant growth, and yield in chili plants.
Design and operation of a laboratory scale photobioreactor for the cultivation of microalgae
(2011) Bhola, Virthie; Bux, Faizal
Due to greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel usage, the impending threat of global climate change has increased. The need for an alternative energy feedstock that is not in direct competition to food production has drawn the focus to microalgae. Research suggests that future advances in microalgal mass culture will require closed systems as most microalgal species of interest thrive in highly selective environments. A high lipid producing microalga, identified as Chlorella vulgaris was isolated from a freshwater pond. To appraise the biofuel potential of the isolated strain, the growth kinetics, pyroletic characteristics and photosynthetic efficiency of the Chlorella sp was evaluated in vitro. The optimised preliminary conditions for higher biomass yield of the selected strain were at 4% CO2, 0.5 g l-1 NaNO3 and 0.04 g l-1 PO4, respectively. Pulse amplitude modulation results indicated that C. vulgaris could withstand a light intensity ranging from 150-350 μmol photons m-2s-1. The pyrolitic studies under inert atmosphere at different heating rates of 15, 30, 40 and 50 ºC min-1 from ambient temperature to 800 oC showed that the overall final weight loss recorded for the four different heating rates was in the range of 78.9 to 81%. A tubular photobioreactor was then designed and utilised for biomass and lipid optimisation. The suspension of microalgae was circulated by a pump and propelled to give a sufficiently turbulent flow periodically through the illuminated part and the dark part of the photobioreactor. Microalgal density was determined daily using a Spectrophotometer. Spectrophotometric determinations of biomass were periodically verified by dry cell weight measurements. Results suggest that the optimal NaNO3 concentration for cell growth in the reactor was around 7.5 g l-1, yielding maximum biomass of 2.09 g l-1 on day 16. This was a significant 2.2 fold increase in biomass (p < 0.005) when compared to results achieved at the lowest NaNO3 cycle (of 3.8 g l-1), which yielded a biomass value of 0.95 g l-1 at an OD of 1.178. Lipid accumulation experiments revealed that the microalga did not accumulate significant amounts of lipids when NaNO3 concentrations in the reactor were beyond 1.5 g l-1 (p > 0.005). The largest lipid fraction occurred when the NaNO3 concentration in the medium was 0.5 g l-1. Results suggest that the optimal trade-off between maximising biomass and lipid content occurs at 0.9 g l-1 NaNO3 among the tested conditions within the photobioreactor. Gas chromatograms showed that even though a greater number of known lipids were produced in Run 8, the total lipid percentage was much lower when compared to Runs 9-13. For maximal biomass and lipid from C. vulgaris, it is therefore crucial to optimise nutritional parameters such as NaNO3. However, suitable growth conditions for C. vulgaris in a tubular photobioreactor calls for innovative technological breakthroughs and therefore work is ongoing globally to address this.
Detection and evaluation of the fate of estrogen endocrine disrupting chemicals in wastewater treatment
(2014) Surujlal-Naicker, Swastika; Bux, Faizal
All over the world concerns have been raised over the possible adverse effects that may occur when exposed to chemicals that have the potential to interfere and affect the endocrine system. The concern is directed at both humans and wildlife. There is still a lack of public awareness regarding Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals (EDCs) and the harmful effects on humans and wildlife. It has only been within the last decade that South Africa began the actual task for proper management and control for water and wastewater quality. There are many ways to detect these EDCs all of which are very laborious and most of the cases these EDCs are either in the pico or nano gram per litre range, too minute for many methods to detect effectively; so therefore the research project aimed to use rapid and sensitive techniques to determine the quickest means to detect the very low concentrations of theses EDCs. Two techniques were researched, i.e., Enzyme Linked immunoassays (ELISAs) and Radio-immunoassays (RIAs). The research study thus assessed the solid phase extraction (SPE) technique for total recovery of hormones; the ELISA and RIA techniques for rapid detection of natural (estrone (E1), estradiol (E2) and estriol (E3) and synthetic ethinylestradiol (EE2) by validating the precision and reproducibility . These techniques were then applied to determine hormone EDC removal first at laboratory scale investigations and then applied to full scale wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) with different configurations in order to deduce removal efficiency of each type of plant. The next phase assessed the toxicity of individual and combined estrogen standards as well as the toxicity in the WWTPs and classify and to determine if there was a correlation between hormone concentration and toxicity in final effluents. The assessment of the SPE and the immunoassay procedures (ELISA AND RIA) using standards and controls found that both these assays can be utilised to quantify hormone estrogens in wastewater. The small sample volume required reduced the labour time and application of the procedure made it cost effective and reliable techniques. The intra-assay and inter-assay validation procedures as well as the standard recoveries confirmed reproducibility and precision of the immunoassays. The % CV were <10% for both the intra-assay and inter-assay validations. The laboratory scale investigations included the operation of a modified Ludzak-Ettinger (MLE) process which enabled control and manipulation over the operational parameters in order to establish how certain parameters influenced the removal of hormone EDCs. One such parameter that was manipulated was the sludge retention time (SRT). The MLE tests showed that the SRTs definitely have an effect on the removal of hormones from the influent as well as the overall performance of sewage treatment. The 10 day SRT proved that longer SRTs will definitely aid in the removal of hormones and possibly other EDCs in raw sewage. During the 10 day SRT the influent hormone concentrations (E1: 59.11 ng/L, E2: 61.40 ng/L) were almost double than the influent hormone concentrations (E1: 26.46 ng/L, E2: 27.60 ng/L) during the 5 day SRT, which impacted on the removal efficiency. The 5 day SRT had an overall average E2 and E1 removal of 78.11% and 81.71% respectively while the 10 day SRT had average E2 and E1 removal of 91.24 % and 80.56% respectively. The 24 hour batch test provided evidence of the reversible metabolism of the E2 hormone. This was seen by the rapid decrease of E2 and the rapid increase of E1 in less than 3 hours, which proved that E2 can be metabolized in to E1. An average reduction of 94.44% of E2 was seen after 5 hours and after 10 hours was no longer detected. After 13 hours E1 could no longer be detected. This finding also provided clarity as to the lower percentage removal of E1 during the 10 day SRT of the MLE process. The Vibrio fischeri biotox method implemented was the most economic and easiest way to conduct the toxicity tests. The validation of the test used a 52.9 mg/L K2Cr2O7 standard which provided a Cr (VI) concentration of 18.7 mg/L in the final test suspension which is the theoretical effective concentration causing 50% inhibition (EC50). This specific concentration of the Cr (VI) exhibited an EC50 at 20.08 mg/L. The toxicity investigations of the individual and mixed hormone standards revealed that at the 10 ng/L concentration the individual E2 standard had the highest percentage inhibition (%INH) of 45.99% after the 30 minute contact time (T30), and when this standard was further diluted to 5 and 1 ng/L also showed higher % INH (26.04 and 23.66 %INH, respectively) than the individual EE2 standard (21.92 %INH) at 10 ng/L. . According to the toxicity classification system and after interpretation of the data, all the hormone standards were classified as Class II as they all exhibited slight acute toxicity. The 10 ng/L E2 standard had Toxicity Units (TU) of 0.8 which was close to the Class III level; however when it was in a mixture with E1 and E3, the TU was much lower (0.6 TU). The synthetic EE2 hormone also showed slight acute toxicity and had the lowest TU of 0.4. The application of the above mentioned techniques to full scale WWTPs with different configurations showed different removal efficiencies. The WWTPs ranged from the most primary consisting of just oxidation ponds to biological trickling filters, to biological nutrient removal (BNR) to conventional activated sludge (AS) plants. Removal rates ranged from 29% to 96% for E2, 0% to 89% for E1 and 0% to 100% for EE2. The overall ranking of the WWTPs from the most efficient to least efficient in terms of hormone removal were as follows: Plant E (91%) = Plant D (before UF) (91%) > Plant B (east side) (88%) > Plant B (west side) (77%) > Plant C (east side) (71%) > Plant D (after UF) (57%) > Plant A (56%) > Plant C (west side) (12%). Using the Vibrio fischeri method to evaluate the reduction of toxicity in WWTPs C, D and E proved effective. It was seen immediately after secondary biological treatment in the clarifier effluent the toxicity was reduced. Plants C, D and E had reduced the toxicities by 100, 80 and 97 % immediately after secondary biological treatment, while after the addition of the Chlorine disinfectant in the final stage of treatment the toxicity increased having %INH of 99.9, 15.7 and 99.9 respectively. In conclusion the SPE can be used as an extraction procedure for hormones in wastewater and the immunoassays can be used as rapid techniques for quantification of hormone EDCs in wastewater. The ELISA technique proved to be the slightly superior to the RIA in terms of facilities required. The laboratory scale procedures proved that some hormones can be oxidised to other hormones and therefore longer sludge retention times may be required to improve the removal. The study of the different WWTPs configuration showed that plant configuration and operational parameters impact the removal of hormone EDCs. The composition of the influent received by the plant also has an effect on the removal, i.e., whether it’s industrial, domestic or a mixture of both. Results concluded that plants which have either mixing and/or aeration with activated sludge and longer SRTs of more than 10 days have a higher rate of hormone removal than those plants with shorter SRTs and that the activated sludge processes were capable of reducing the toxicity of the influent. Overall results indicated that hormone EDCs are indeed being discharged with the effluents from WWTPs in South Africa. However whether the concentrations left in the final effluents will still have an adverse effect on the aquatic life is a question that still remains unanswered. The aquatic ecosystems are inevitably being polluted with these EDCs and their breakdown products.
Detection and quantification of nitrifying bacteria from South African biological nutrient removal plants
(2013-07-30) Ramdhani, Nishani; Bux, Faizal; Pillai, Sheena Kumari Kuttan
Nitrification is a crucial step in biological nutrient removal (BNR) processes, mostly carried out by a group of nitrifying bacteria which includes ammonia-oxidising bacteria (AOB) and nitrite-oxidising bacteria (NOB). Nitrification failure has proven to be a common operational problem in full-scale wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) since nitrifying bacteria are very sensitive to sudden changes in environmental or plant operating conditions. The current investigation was carried out to advance our understanding of the distribution of nitrifying bacterial populations and their performance at three different BNR plants in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. The latest molecular techniques such as fluorescent in situ hybridisation (FISH)-confocal scanning laser microscopy (CSLM), polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and real-time quantitative PCR (Q-PCR) were applied to detect and quantify nitrifying bacteria. When using FISH to target the nitrifying population, it necessitated optimising pre-treatment protocols of the samples to improve accuracy during quantification. Sonication was found to be the superior method of dispersion based on the least disruption of nitrifier cell integrity, irrespective of the sludge type. The effect of plant configurations and wastewater characteristics on the distribution of the nitrifying bacterial population and subsequently on the nitrification performance was evaluated using FISH and PCR. FISH results revealed the dominance of Nitrosomonas (AOB), Nitrobacter (NOB) and Nitrospira (NOB) for all BNR plants. The 16S rRNA analysis of PCR products using genus-specific primers, revealed the presence of more than one species of the same group at these plants. Nitrosomonas spp. including Nitrosomonas halophila, Nitrosomonas eutropha, Nitrosomonas europaea, Nitrosomonas aestuarii and an unidentified Nitrosomonas spp. were found to dominate among the AOB and Nitrobacter vulgaris, Nitrobacter alkalicus, Nitrobacter hamburgensis and an unidentified Nitrobacter spp. were the dominant species for NOB. Among these species, Nitrosomonas aestuarii, Nitrosomonas europaea, Nitrobacter hamburgensis were detected only from the industrial wastewater samples. The efficiency of two commonly used techniques viz., FISH and Q-PCR for the detection of nitrifiers from WWTP were also studied and compared, specifically targeting Nitrobacter sp. Even though there were slight variations in the quantification results, changes in the Nitrobacter community at these plants were consistent for both FISH and Q-PCR results. Both techniques have their own limitations and advantages. This study has helped to add to the platform of understanding the distribution and activity of nitrifying bacteria by correlating population dynamics with the operational parameters at full-scale level. The observations made in this study will assist researchers and engineers to minimise future nitrification failure at full-scale BNR plants. This study also confirmed the highly complex activities of wastewater treatment processes, which is dependant on a number of factors. Specific AOB or NOB predominant in wastewater rather suggests that the wastewater type and characteristics may contribute to significantly different microbial environments. Among the AOB, Nitrosomonas dominated at all BNR plants throughout the study period and for NOB both Nitrobacter and Nitrospira were found in significant numbers but their dominance varied across the plants. These dissimilar, distinct distribution patterns could be attributed to their environment which in turn impacted on the nitrification performance of the system. It was also noted that the co-existence of more than one group of these communities at the same plant could help the plant escape complete functional failures such as nitrification, due to sudden changes in temperature and substrate concentrations, as this function can be performed by different groups. Although it would have been meritorious to conduct a nitrogen balance in this study, this was not possible since the research focused on full-scale systems.
Determination of the relationship between epiphytes and selected filamentous bacteria in activated sludge
(2016) Conco, Thobela; Bux, Faizal; Sheena Kumari, S.K.; Stenström, Thor-Axel
Activated sludge (AS) flocs are paramount in biological treatment of wastewater, are comprised of microbial consortia with organic and inorganic material bound together by extra polymeric substances (EPS). The filamentous bacteria play a vital role in the floc formation process by providing the necessary structural support. Presence of epiphytic attachment on selected filamentous bacteria is a commonly occurring phenomenon in activated sludge samples. Different theories have been proposed to describe this phenomenon; however, not much research has been carried out to explore the profundity of the attachment. In this study, an attempt has been made to elucidate the intrinsic nature of the epiphytic attachment between the bacterial rods and filamentous bacteria based on microscopic (morphological and structural) analysis. Characterization of these epiphytes were performed using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) at group level using Alpha, Beta and Gamma Proteo-bacterial probes. Morphological characteristics of filament hosts and the bacterial rods at the interface region was assessed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The SEM micrographs indicated that the attachment was facilitated by more than the EPS layer. Further ultrastructural examination using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) indicated a possible cell-to-cell interaction between epiphytes and the selected filaments. Fibrillar structures resembling amyloid-like proteins were observed within the filament cell targeted by the epiphytes. An interaction was apparent between the amyloid like proteins and the epiphytes as exhibited by the direction of fibrillar structures pointing towards the approaching epiphytes. Common bacterial appendages such as pili and fimbria were absent at the interface and further noted was the presence of cell membrane extensions on the epiphytic bacteria protruding towards the targeted filamentous cell. The sheath of host filaments however, remained intact and unpenetrated, during colonization. Amyloid-like fibrils at interface may potentially play the role of attachment sites for the attaching epiphytes, as attachment facilitating appendages were not visualized.
Determining the efficiency of the anammox process for the treatment of high- ammonia influent wastewater
(2017-08) Gokal, Jashan; Bux, Faizal; Stenström, Thor-Axel; Kumari, Sheena K.
Domestic wastewater contains a high nutrient load, primarily in the form of Carbon (C), Nitrogen (N), and Phosphorous (P) compounds. If left untreated, these nutrients can cause eutrophication in receiving environments. Biological wastewater treatment utilizes a suspension of microorganisms that metabolize this excess nutrient load. Nitrogen removal in these systems are due to the synergistic processes of nitrification and denitrification, each of which requires its own set of operating parameters and controlling microbial groups. An alternative N-removal pathway termed the anammox process allows for total N-removal in a single step under anoxic conditions. This process, mediated by the anammox bacterial group, requires no organic carbon, produces negligible greenhouse gases and requires almost 50 % less energy than the conventional process, making it a promising new technology for efficient and cost-effective N-removal. In this study, a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) was established for the autotrophic removal of N-rich wastewater through an anammox-centric bacterial consortia. The key microbial members of this consortia were characterized and quantified over time using molecular methods and next generation sequencing to determine if the operational conditions had any effect on the seed inoculum population composition. Additionally, local South African wastewater treatment plants were screened for the presence of anammox bacteria through 16S rRNA amplification and enrichment in different reactor types. A 3 L bench scale SBR was inoculated with active biomass (~ 5 % (v/v)) sourced from a parent anammox enrichment reactor, and maintained at a temperature of 35 °C ± 1 °C. The reactor was fed with a synthetic wastewater medium containing no organic C, minimal dissolved oxygen (< 0.5 mg/L), and N in the form of ammonium and nitrite in the ratio of 1:1.3. The reactor was operated for a period of 366 days and the effluent ammonium, nitrite and nitrate were measured during this period. The hydraulic retention time was controlled at 4.55 days from Day 1 to Day 250, and thereafter shortened to 1.52 days from Day 251 to Day 360 due to an increased nitrogen removal rate (NRR). During Phase I of operation (Day 1 to Day 150), the reactor performance gradually increased up to an NRR of ~160 mg N/day. During Phase II (Day 151 to Day 250), the overall reactor performance decreased with the NRR decreasing to ~90 mg N/day, while Phase III (Day 251 to Day 366) displayed a gradual recovery of NRR back to the reactor optimum of ~160 mg N/day. The accumulation of nitrate in the effluent during the latter parts of Phase II and Phase III, coupled with oxygen ingress (~2.1 mg/L) in the same period, indicated that it was not the anammox pathway that was dominating N-removal within the reactor, but more likely the second half of the nitrification pathway mediated by the nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB). This was further confirmed through molecular analysis, which indicated that the bacterial population had shifted significantly over the course of reactor operation. Quantitative PCR methods displayed a decrease in all the key N-removing population groups from Day 1 to Day 140, and a marginal increase in anammox and aerobic ammonia oxidizing bacteria from Day 140 – Day 260. From Day 300 onwards, NOB had started dominating the system, simultaneously suppressing the growth of other N-removing bacterial groups. Despite this, the NRR peaked during this period, indicating an alternative mechanism for ammonia removal within the reactor system. A total population analysis using NGS was also performed, which corroborated the QPCR results and displayed a population shift away from anammox bacteria towards predominantly NOB and members of the phylum Chloroflexi. The proliferation of aerobic NOB and Chloroflexi, and the suppression of anammox bacteria, indicated that DO ingress was indeed the primary cause of the population shift within the reactor. Despite this population shift, N-removal within the reactor remained high. New pathways have recently emerged which implicate these two groups as potential N oxidizers, with specific NOB groups showing the ability for oxidation of ammonia through the comammox process, and members of the Phylum Chloroflexi being capable of nitrite reduction. This could imply that an alternate pathway was responsible for the majority of N-removal within the system, in addition to the anammox and conventional nitrification pathways. Additionally, in an attempt to detect a local anammox reservoir, eleven wastewater systems from around South Africa were screened for the presence of anammox bacteria. Through direct and nested PCR-based screening, anammox bacteria was not detectable in any of the activated sludge samples tested. Based on the operating conditions of the source wastewater systems, a subset of three sludge samples were selected for further enrichment. After 60-110 days of enrichment in multiple reactor configurations, only one reactor sample tested positive for the presence of anammox bacteria. Although this result indicates that anammox bacteria might not be ubiquitous within every biological wastewater system, it is more likely that anammox bacteria might only be present at undetectable levels, and that an extended enrichment prior to screening is necessary for a true representation of anammox bacterial prevalence in an environmental sample.
Development and assessment of a membrane bioreactor for wastewater treatment
(2001) Osifo, Peter Ogbemudia; Bux, Faizal
A woven fibre membrane unit was developed locally and used for this study. The membrane unit was submerged in the aerobic tank of an anoxic-aerobic biological treatment process to treat dairy effluent. Another unit similar to the process above was also set up but with a gravity settling tank replacing the membrane unit. Kinetic studies were done on both processes and their results compared. Effluent characteristics of both processes were also compared. For the membrane bioreactor, the effectiveness of two backflush methods ie air and water, were tested. In this study it was discovered that air backflush could remove the clogging formed at external and internal pores of the membrane better than water backflush measured in terms of rate of pressure recovery and energy consumption. The effluent quality of the membrane bioreactor (MBR) in terms of COD, nitrogen, suspended solids and turbidity was excellent under all conditions tested and was better than conventional activated sludge system. The COD removed based on the average value in MBR was 96.02 % compared to 94 % conventional system. A mass balance of the processes showed that 79 % in the form of nitrogen fed into both the MBR and conventional systems was denitrified. The effluent suspended solids from the MBR was not determinable while that of conventional system was 2.09 mglL. Maximum specific nitrification rate determined graphically was 3.0 d-I and 2.10 d-I in conventional and MBR respectively. The smaller value of nitrification rate in MBR could be attributed to large number of nitrifier volatile suspended solids in the system. The estimated true yield and decay rate coefficients of conventional system is 0.204 kgVSS/kgCOD and 0.013 d-I respectively. The flux obtained from this study is between 22 and 92 L/m2.h. However, the average flux value is 57 L/m2.h for the whole period of operation. Regular flux decline observed during operation was improved through regular backwash with air and chemical cleaning. The transmembrane pressure did not as whole increase more than 55 kPa due to frequent cleaning of the membrane surface.
Development and optimization of remedial measures to control filamentous bacteria in a full-scale biological nutrient removal plant
(2014) Deepnarain, Nashia; Bux, Faizal
Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) frequently experience bulking and foaming episodes, which present operational challenges by affecting sludge settling due to the excessive proliferation of filamentous bacteria. Various control strategies have been implemented over the years to minimize filamentous growth, however, filamentous bulking still remains an unresolved problem in many WWTPs worldwide. The current study focused on developing and optimizing remedial measures viz., specific and non-specific methods to reduce problematic filamentous bacteria in a full-scale WWTP. Specific methods demonstrated the influence of plant operational parameters viz. chemical oxygen demand, influent N-NH4+, food to microorganism ratio, dissolved oxygen, temperature and pH on the abundance of filamentous bacteria. A cumulative logit model was used to determine the significant relationships between the individual filamentous bacteria at present and the prevailing plant operational parameters. Using the above statistical approach, significant observations and predictions were made with respect to the individual filamentous growth under certain operational parameters. With further validation, this model could be successfully applied to other full-scale WWTPs identifying specific parameters that could contribute to filamentous bulking, thus providing a useful guide for regulating specific filamentous growth. Non-specific control methods such as chlorine, ultraviolet irradiation and ozone treatment were investigated on filamentous bacteria using a live/dead staining technique. To achieve at least 50% reduction of filamentous bacteria, a chlorine dose of 10 mg Cl2/L was required, all filaments were killed at a dose of 22 mg Cl2/L. In addition, an effective UV and ozone dose of 4418.91 μw seconds/cm2 and ±20 mg O3/L respectively, was required to kill 50% of the filamentous bacterial population. Among the three non-specific methods, ozone treatment seemed to be an effective method in controlling the filamentous population with a low negative impact to the surrounding environment. This study serves as a useful guide on the problems and control of filamentous bulking in activated sludge plants.
Development and optimization of technology for the extraction and conversion of micro algal lipids to biodiesel
(2015) Ramluckan, Krishan; Moodley, Kandasamy Govindsamy; Bux, Faizal
Fossil fuel reserves have been diminishing worldwide thus making them very scarce in the long term. These fuel sources and their by-products which are used commercially tend to produce large quantities of emissions. Some of them are believed to be toxic to flora and fauna. It is primarily for this reason that researchers worldwide have begun to seek out alternative sources of environmentally safe fuel. Biodiesel from algae is one of these sources that have been examined over the last few decades. Biodiesel has been produced from other plant-based material and waste oils in countries like America and Japan. However, the use of food based crops for biodiesel production has been challenged as it has an impact on food production on an international scale. Algae have only recently been investigated for their feasibility for biodiesel production on a large scale. The aim of this study was to investigate and develop technologies for biodiesel production from algae. The species of algae chosen were chlorella sp and scenedesmus sp., since they are indigeneous to Kwazulu Natal in South Africa. Samples were obtained from a local raceway pond and prepared for analysis. Drying protocols used freeze, oven and sun drying for initial preparation of the samples for analysis. Sun drying was the least energy intensive but most time consuming. At laboratory scale, oven drying was chosen as the best alternative. Lipid extraction methods investigated were the separating funnel method, the soxhlet method, microwave assisted extraction (MAE) and the expeller press. Thirteen solvents covering a range of polarities were used with the extraction methods to determine the efficiency of the solvent with these methods. Optimization of the MAE method was conducted using both the one factor at a time (OFAT) method and a design of experiment (DOE) statistical method. The shelf life of algal biomass was determined by ageing the samples for approximately three months. Direct and in-situ transesterification of lipid extracts to produce biodiesel was investigated using both acid and base catalysis. Qualitative and quantitative analyses were conducted using Fourier transform infra-red (FTIR) and gas chromatography (GC). Chemical and physical characterization of the biodiesel produced from the algal lipid extracts were compared to both local and international standard specifications for biodiesel. In terms of extraction efficiency, it was found that soxhlet and microwave assisted extraction methods were almost equally good. This was proved by the MAE method yielding an average of 10.0% lipids for chloroform, ethanol and hexane after 30 mL of solvent was used in an extraction time of 10 minutes, while the soxhlet method yielded 10.36% lipids using an extraction volume of 100 mL of solvent with an extraction time of 3 hours. Chloroform, ethanol and hexane were more efficient than the other ten solvents used. This was shown by these three solvents producing lipid quantities between 10% to 11% while all the other solvents produced lipid quantities between 2 and 10 %. The best extraction efficiency was achieved by the binary solvent mixture made up of chloroform and ethanol in a 1:1 ratio. Under the conditions optimized, this solvent ratio yielded a lipid content of 11.76%. The methods chosen and optimized for extraction are very efficient, but the actual cost of production of biodiesel need to be determined. Physical methods like the expeller press are not feasible for extraction of the type of biomass produced unless algae are pelletized to improve extraction. This will impact on the cost of producing biodiesel. The transesterification protocols investigated show that the base catalysis produced biodiesel with a ratio of saturates to unsaturates conducive to a good fuel product. The direct esterification method in this study proved to be better than the in-situ method for biodiesel production. The in-situ method was also more labour intensive. Chromatography was found to be a fast and efficient method for qualitative and quantitative determination of biodiesel. Characterization tests showed that the quality of biodiesel produced was satisfactory. It also showed that the methods used in this study were feasible for the satisfactory production of biodiesel which meets local and international specifications.